The gang goes hunting for secondhand stories and grab a pair from that swap meet of scary(?) accounts, NoSleep. Both of them have a garage sale in their title, and both are highly rated, but is NoSleep's treasure the Committee's trash?
"I Never Should've Stopped at That Garage Sale" is credited to TheBigSp00k; "I am so Glad you Stopped at my Garage Sale" is credited to Hayong.